Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Economic Dynamism
Published on
Jul 2, 2025
Contributors
Gabriel Gasave
Martin Simonetta
ChatGPT image

US, China, and Latin America Relations: Challenges and Opportunities

Contributors
Gabriel Gasave
Gabriel Gasave
Gabriel Gasave
Martin Simonetta
Martin Simonetta
Martin Simonetta
Summary
China’s assertive rise and U.S. protectionism place Latin America at a crossroads, as it balances investments and political influence from both powers while striving to maintain autonomy and long-term development stability.

Summary
China’s assertive rise and U.S. protectionism place Latin America at a crossroads, as it balances investments and political influence from both powers while striving to maintain autonomy and long-term development stability.

Listen to this article

Following the fall of the Berlin Wall, Francis Fukuyama famously coined the phrase “the end of history” to characterize a new epoch marked by liberal democracy and American-style capitalism’s perceived triumph over Soviet communism. Several decades later, however, this assertion appears increasingly contested, as the United States no longer holds unchallenged dominance in the global arena of ideas and geopolitics.

The End of the “End of History”

China—alongside Russia, asserting its influence from its Eurasian position—has increasingly positioned itself as a challenger to the United States’s once-undisputed global leadership. Once regarded as the West’s “spoiled child,” China’s U.S.-supported accession to the World Trade Organization in 2001 marked a pivotal moment in its ascent. Today, the Asian power openly contests American authority on the world stage. It is essential to recognize that China’s civilizational heritage spans over 5,100 years—well preceding the People’s Republic’s establishment in 1949. In recent decades, China has emerged as a rapidly growing economic power, attracting substantial foreign direct investment, particularly from the U.S., due to its political stability, manufacturing reliability, high productivity, and cost competitiveness relative to Western economies.

This solid economic foundation has enabled China to shift from a defensive posture to a more assertive and expansionist global role. Its geopolitical and geoeconomic engagement in Latin America exemplifies a deliberate long-term strategy aimed at extending its global influence. Under Xi Jinping’s leadership, China has become increasingly aware of its strategic imperative to secure access to markets and natural resources to sustain its over 1.4 billion people, nearly one-fifth of the world’s population. At the same time, China’s political system, rooted in an authoritarian model, stands in stark contrast to the West’s republican democracies. Various international assessments, such as those produced by the non-governmental organization Freedom House, consistently rank China as “not free” in terms of civil and political liberties. This assessment underscores the profound ideological divergence between the Chinese model and the democratic norms many Western nations uphold.

In contrast, the United States has pursued a foreign policy shaped by the imperatives of transparency and the institutional constraints inherent in its democratic system, where each incoming administration often shifts priorities and strategies. Within this framework, principles such as “America for the Americans,” which underpinned the Monroe Doctrine of 1823, sought to limit European involvement in the Western Hemisphere. Over time, however, this doctrine evolved into a policy more focused on fostering private-sector cooperation, particularly in the context of U.S. engagement with Latin America.

Today, the United States remains the leading source of foreign direct investment (F.D.I.) in Latin America, followed by Spain and the Netherlands. In 1994, the U.S. sought to deepen economic integration across the hemisphere through the proposed Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA). The initiative did not, however, progress beyond its early stages and triggered intense nationalist backlash in several countries, most notably Venezuela, where President Hugo Chávez denounced the FTAA as "a new attempt at invasion and colonialism." His infamous phrase, “FTAA? ¡Al carajo!”, became emblematic of the widespread opposition in parts of the region. In the wake of this setback, the United States shifted its approach, pursuing a series of bilateral and regional trade agreements. Among the most significant are the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) with Mexico and Canada, and the Dominican Republic–Central America Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA-DR), which includes Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, and the Dominican Republic.

Trump’s New Game

These U.S. initiatives were rooted in the post–World War II logic that free trade would serve as the nation’s most effective ambassador, promoting peace, prosperity, and reducing authoritarianism’s global appeal. China’s rise, however, has introduced a far more rapid and assertive development strategy that contrasts starkly with the more cautious diplomatic approaches Western powers traditionally favor. China’s lack of institutional constraints and the absence of clear separations among its branches of power have enabled it to act with greater speed and decisiveness than the United States. Strategic Chinese investments in important infrastructure—such as ports, cold storage facilities, railroads, and energy projects—underscore its commitment to building a “global silk road” aimed at expanding its economic and geopolitical influence.

Since Donald Trump’s election to a second term, U.S. trade policy has taken a marked turn toward protectionism. His administration’s withdrawal from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (T.P.P.) and the renegotiation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) reflected a broader shift toward prioritizing domestic economic interests over multilateral commitments. This “America First” approach has introduced a degree of uncertainty, particularly in Latin America, where many governments fear that reduced access to the U.S. market could adversely affect their export-driven economies.

Latin America finds itself at a crossroads amid China’s growing influence and the United States’s turn toward protectionism, which places the region in a complex and delicate position. Latin American countries are increasingly compelled to navigate among competing global powers to diversify their economic and political partnerships. China offers large-scale investments with fewer governance and transparency conditions than Western democracies typically demand, but the United States remains a key trade and investment partner, albeit with a more isolationist posture. The region’s challenge lies in managing this strategic rivalry without compromising its autonomy and ability to negotiate balanced agreements that serve Latin America’s development goals, without becoming overly dependent on either superpower. Successfully walking this tightrope will be critical for ensuring the region’s long-term prosperity and geopolitical stability.

Gabriel Gasave is director of the Center for Global Prosperity at the Independent Institute and a member of BeLatin. He received his master’s degree in economics and business administration from the Graduate School of Economics and Business Administration (ESEADE) in Buenos Aires and his law degree from the University of Buenos Aires.

Martin Simonetta is executive director of Fundación Atlas para una Sociedad Libre. He holds a bachelor’s degree in international relations (Universidad del Salvador) and an M.A in International Economic Policy. (Universidad de Belgrano). He has completed a Graduate Program in Positive Psychology (Fundación Foro).

10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

The Education of David Mamet

Pursuit of Happiness
Aug 15, 2025

Chicago: The First Domino to Fall?

Politics
Aug 14, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Economic Dynamism

AI and the Future of Society and Economy

Large language and generative AI models like ChatGPT are the equivalent of the first automobiles: fun to play with, somewhat unreliable, and maybe a little dangerous. But over time, the lesson for will be clear: Who Learns Fastest, Wins.

Joel Kotkin, Marshall Toplansky
Economic Dynamism
Jul 17, 2025
Automated Detection of Emotion in Central Bank Communication: A Warning

Can LLMs help us better understand the role of emotion in central bank communication?

Carola Binder, Nicole Baerg
Economic Dynamism
Jul 1, 2025
Defending Technological Dynamism & the Freedom to Innovate in the Age of AI

Human flourishing, economic growth, and geopolitical resilience requires innovation—especially in artificial intelligence.

Adam Thierer
Economic Dynamism
Jun 6, 2025
Partisan Trust in the Federal Reserve

This paper examines partisanship in public perceptions of the Federal Reserve.

Carola Binder, Cody Couture, Abhiprerna Smit
Economic Dynamism
Apr 22, 2025
No items found.
How We Built the Arsenal of Democracy

By unleashing the energy, creativity, and drive of the private sector to rebuild our defense-industrial base, we can trigger a tech-industrial revival of the American economy.

Arthur Herman
Economic Dynamism
Jul 25, 2025
The $130 Billion Train That Couldn’t

California’s High Speed Rail is only the latest blue-state infrastructure failure.

Joel Kotkin
Economic Dynamism
Jul 21, 2025
Students from China Are Essential for America

An appropriately curated student visa policy in vital research fields like AI and quantum can combine careful risk management with common sense. The benefits to the U.S. will last for generations.

Arthur Herman, Christopher Monroe
Economic Dynamism
Jul 8, 2025
Firm Investment and the User Cost of Capital: New U.S. Corporate Tax Reform Evidence

This working paper analyzes the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 to examine how corporate tax reform impacts rates of investment.

Jonathan S. Hartley, Kevin A. Hassett, Joshua D. Rauh
Economic Dynamism
Jul 7, 2025

Why the Damage to Fed Independence May Have Already Been Done

Economic Dynamism
Jul 24, 2025
1:05

Richard Epstein: Law and Economics of Public Sector Unions

Economic Dynamism
Jun 19, 2025
1:05

Can the U.S. Defense Industrial Base Meet Today’s Challenges?

Economic Dynamism
May 13, 2025
1:05

Virginia Postrel and Adam Thierer on Big Trends and Big Ideas in Dynamism

Economic Dynamism
Apr 29, 2025
1:05

Joel Mokyr on American Dynamism vs. Techno-pessimism

Economic Dynamism
Apr 29, 2025
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
Slowly Strangling the Pharmaceutical Industry

Unlike many private uses of monopoly power, a government monopoly, backed by state force, can last a long time.

Richard Epstein
Economic Dynamism
Aug 13, 2025
The Hidden Cost of Federal Deficit Spending

We face a much more troubling debt problem than we’ve ever experienced in American history, and addressing it can only be achieved with significant entitlement program reform.

David C. Rose
Economic Dynamism
Aug 12, 2025
The Fictions Holding Down the Economy

When crises from statist economic policies happen, “the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around.”

Dominic Pino
Economic Dynamism
Aug 7, 2025
The Fed Has Gone Adrift—It’s Time to End The Bureaucratic Mission Creep

The Federal Reserve must do less—and do it better.

Jon Hartley
Economic Dynamism
Aug 5, 2025
No items found.