Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Constitutionalism
Published on
Jan 29, 2024
Contributors
John Yoo
A stylized TikTok logo generated by ChatGPT (OpenAI, 01/30/2025)

Trump and Foley Are Wrong on the TikTok Law

Contributors
John Yoo
John Yoo
Senior Research Fellow
John Yoo
Summary

There is no serious claim that the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act is unconstitutional.

Summary

There is no serious claim that the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act is unconstitutional.

Listen to this article

I am no stranger to advising presidents that they can resist intrusions into their constitutional powers. Nevertheless, I couldn’t help but disagree with Elizabeth Price Foley’s op-ed “Trump’s Reprieve for TikTok Is Legitimate” (Jan. 27).

Article II of the Constitution vests the president with “the executive power” of the U.S. and recognizes his authority as commander in chief. As Alexander Hamilton observed in Federalist No. 75, “the execution of the laws and the employment of the common strength either for this purpose or for the common defense, seem to comprise all the functions of the executive magistrate.” If Congress orders a war against the president’s wishes or makes an alliance he doesn’t seek, it has violated the Constitution.

But there is a world of difference between those cases and the TikTok law. Congress exercised its authority under Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution “to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations.” There is no serious claim that the law is unconstitutional, especially after a unanimous Supreme Court rejected TikTok’s free-speech claims on Jan. 17. This renders off point the claim that President Trump can refuse to enforce the law because it is just like Congress forbidding him from firing cabinet officials or waging war in the most effective way.

Continue reading the entire article at the Wall Street Journal

10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

Suspending Habeas Corpus: A Lincolnian Guide

Constitutionalism
May 20, 2025

Speaker Trump

Constitutionalism
May 20, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Constitutionalism

Religious Exemptions?: What the Free Exercise Clause Means

A conversation among three religious liberty scholars on the Free Exercise Clause’s original meaning.

Andrew Koppelman, Michael McConnell, Vincent Phillip Muñoz
Constitutionalism
Apr 28, 2025
Rational Nondelegation

The nondelegation doctrine, which forbids Congress from transferring excessive power to the executive branch, has risen from the dead.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
Feb 27, 2025
What is an Establishment of Religion? And What Does Disestablishment Require?

Vincent Phillip Muñoz reviews a new book about the Establishment Clause.

Vincent Phillip Muñoz
Constitutionalism
Dec 16, 2024

Law Talk

Welcome to Law Talk with Richard Epstein and John Yoo. Our show is hosted by Charles C. W. Cooke.

View all
** items
Trump, Lincoln and a ‘Habeas Corpus Threat’

Prof. John Yoo replies to William Galston.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
May 18, 2025
The Originalist Case for Birthright Citizenship

A Supreme Court guided by originalist principles should affirm the constitutionality of birthright citizenship.

John Yoo, Robert Delahunty
Constitutionalism
May 9, 2025
Burnham’s Counterrevolution

Richard Reinsch reviews David T. Byrne's new biography of James Burnham.

Richard M. Reinsch II
Constitutionalism
Mar 28, 2025
How Not to Run the World

John Yoo examines Straussian approaches to foreign policy.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
Mar 23, 2025

Yuval Levin on How the Constitution Unified our Nation – and Could Again

Constitutionalism
Mar 27, 2025
1:05

WSJ: The Legal Theory Behind Trump’s Plan to Consolidate Power

Constitutionalism
Mar 11, 2025
1:05

Litigation Update: Department of State v. AIDS Vaccine Advocacy Coalition

Constitutionalism
Mar 7, 2025
1:05

John Yoo: Supreme Court Temporarily Allows Trump’s Freeze on USAID Payments

Constitutionalism
Feb 27, 2025
1:05

John Yoo: President Trump Is Trying to Restore Energy to the Executive

Constitutionalism
Feb 19, 2025
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
Suspending Habeas Corpus: A Lincolnian Guide

Trump White House officials may believe that the illegal entry of millions of aliens, with drug dealers and terrorists mixed in, qualifies as an invasion. But the Founders would not have seen it that way.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
May 20, 2025
Speaker Trump

Donald Trump could revive a moribund Congress.

Joseph Postell
Constitutionalism
May 20, 2025
There Is No Birthright Citizenship for Children Born of Aliens within the United States

Birthright citizenship is not required by our constitutional law.

Richard Epstein
Constitutionalism
May 16, 2025
Why We Can’t Quit Racial Redistricting

The racial redistricting madness created by the Supreme Court happened because some justices claimed the power to rewrite laws to fit their enlightened views about social policy.

GianCarlo Canaparo
Constitutionalism
May 16, 2025
No items found.