Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Constitutionalism
Published on
May 9, 2025
Contributors
John Yoo
Robert Delahunty

The Originalist Case for Birthright Citizenship

Contributors
John Yoo
John Yoo
Senior Research Fellow
John Yoo
Robert Delahunty
Robert Delahunty
Robert Delahunty
Summary
A Supreme Court guided by originalist principles should affirm the constitutionality of birthright citizenship.
Summary
A Supreme Court guided by originalist principles should affirm the constitutionality of birthright citizenship.
Listen to this article

On his first day in office, President Donald Trump ordered a wholesale change in the federal government's immigration policies. The central symbolic issue was birthright citizenship. In an executive order titled "Protecting the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship," Trump forbade the government from recognizing the citizenship of any child born in the United States to parents who are not American citizens or permanent-resident aliens. The order has thus far attracted three major lawsuits as well as four unfavorable district-court decisions. On May 15, 2025, the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in these cases.

Trump's executive order was intended to deliver on his campaign promise to reduce illegal immigration and deport millions of immigrants who have entered the country unlawfully. But the truth is that birthright citizenship has little to do with the real problems plaguing our nation's immigration system. The Pew Research Center estimates that, within the 22 million U.S. households that include an unauthorized immigrant, 1.3 million individuals were born to illegal aliens, even as an estimated 3 million illegal aliens crossed the southern border annually during the Biden administration. Our immigration system broke down not because of our nation's practice of granting citizenship to all born within the country's borders, but because the Biden administration refused to secure the southern border and enforce existing law. Ending birthright citizenship would thus do little to slow illegal migration.

Continue reading at National Affairs

10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

The “Baneful Practice of Secessions” Returns to Texas

Constitutionalism
Aug 27, 2025

Will California Reform Its Broken Housing Policies?

Economic Dynamism
Aug 26, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Constitutionalism

Epstein & Yoo: Amicus Brief in Supreme Court of Maryland

Civitas Senior Research Fellows Richard Epstein and John Yoo, alongside the Mountain States Legal Foundation, filed an amicus brief in the Supreme Court of Maryland.

Richard Epstein, John Yoo
Constitutionalism
Jul 24, 2025
Religious Exemptions?: What the Free Exercise Clause Means

A conversation among three religious liberty scholars on the Free Exercise Clause’s original meaning.

Andrew Koppelman, Michael McConnell, Vincent Phillip Muñoz
Constitutionalism
Apr 28, 2025
Rational Nondelegation

The nondelegation doctrine, which forbids Congress from transferring excessive power to the executive branch, has risen from the dead.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
Feb 27, 2025
What is an Establishment of Religion? And What Does Disestablishment Require?

Vincent Phillip Muñoz reviews a new book about the Establishment Clause.

Vincent Phillip Muñoz
Constitutionalism
Dec 16, 2024

The Libertarian

The inimitable Richard Epstein offers his unique perspective on national developments in public policy and the law.

View all
** items

Law Talk

Welcome to Law Talk with Richard Epstein and John Yoo. Our show is hosted by Charles C. W. Cooke.

View all
** items
Democracy in Britain: The Lords’ Work

Part 2: How the “hereditary peers” enhance lawmaking and support the soft power of the UK.

David L. Leal
Constitutionalism
Aug 6, 2025
The American Revolutions of 1776

America's founding was animated by both the spirit of liberty and the spirit of religion — a philosophical and practical achievement worth understanding and attempting to recover today.

Vincent Philip Muñoz
Constitutionalism
Jun 23, 2025
The Progressive Presidency Envelops American Politics

One does not need to revisit the drastic consequences that ensued from COVID-19 policies to be reminded of the failures and mistakes of the progressive constitutional framework that issued them.

Richard M. Reinsch II
Constitutionalism
May 27, 2025
Trump, Lincoln and a ‘Habeas Corpus Threat’

Prof. John Yoo replies to William Galston.

John Yoo
Constitutionalism
May 18, 2025

Why Postliberalism Is Gaining Ground: Phillip Muñoz on America’s Founding Values

Constitutionalism
Aug 7, 2025
1:05

Richard Epstein: The Constitution, Parental Rights, and More

Constitutionalism
Jul 7, 2025
1:05

Yuval Levin on How the Constitution Unified our Nation – and Could Again

Constitutionalism
Mar 27, 2025
1:05

WSJ: The Legal Theory Behind Trump’s Plan to Consolidate Power

Constitutionalism
Mar 11, 2025
1:05

Litigation Update: Department of State v. AIDS Vaccine Advocacy Coalition

Constitutionalism
Mar 7, 2025
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
The “Baneful Practice of Secessions” Returns to Texas

Secession is an extraordinary tactic that should not be deployed for light and transient causes.

Joseph Postell
Constitutionalism
Aug 27, 2025
Why Issues of Birthright Citizenship Are So Difficult

What makes this issue so difficult is that all these positions have evidence to support them.

Robert G. Natelson
Constitutionalism
Aug 19, 2025
Making Sense of the Court's Establishment Clause Doctrine

Chapman and McConnell acknowledge the judicial excesses of older caselaw and orient the doctrine toward a collection of historically sensitive second-best arrangements looking forward.

Kevin C. Walsh
Constitutionalism
Aug 18, 2025
Civitas Conversations: Is the Court Appeasing the Trump Administration?

A Conversation with Jonathan Adler about judicial overreach v. judicial limits.

Jonathan H. Adler, Richard M. Reinsch II
Constitutionalism
Aug 6, 2025
No items found.