Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Politics
Published on
Apr 7, 2025
Contributors
Richard M. Reinsch II
Photo by Jeremiah Amaya on Unsplash

Mahmoud Khalil Invites America to Judgment

Contributors
Richard M. Reinsch II
Richard M. Reinsch II
Editor-in-Chief, Civitas Outlook
Richard M. Reinsch II
Summary
A free and good society cannot be ‘open’ to everything, no matter how ugly or pernicious.
Summary
A free and good society cannot be ‘open’ to everything, no matter how ugly or pernicious.
Listen to this article

Predictably, many of the arguments made on behalf of ceasing deportation proceedings against Mahmoud Khalil — a lawful resident alien — turn on his supposed status as a political prisoner of the Trump administration. Those making this case argue that Khalil faces the imminent prospect of deportation because he dared speak on behalf of Palestinian freedom and for the Palestinian victims of Israel’s merciless bombing campaign while he was a graduate student at Columbia University. His incredibly deep legal team is now presenting a set of familiar arguments grounded in America’s commitments to free speech. However, they do so in a manner that demands those commitments be open to virtually any speech claim. They also elide the crucial distinction between citizens and non-citizens.

The government credibly believes Khalil to be a leader of pro-Hamas agitation on Columbia’s campus. At one point, the school suspended him for his activities but then reversed its decision. He was a lead negotiator for Columbia University’s Apartheid Divest (CUAD) during its various encampments and invasions of campus property. CUAD, you will recall, extolled Hamas during its protests, celebrated October 7, and declared its encampment at Columbia a “Zionist Free Zone.” Khalil has troubling ties to the organization, which released a statement that “we support liberation by any means necessary, including armed resistance.” Juden Frei.

CUAD believes that it is advancing the cause of liberation by favoring Hamas and related terror groups who wage war against Israel. The New York Times reported that on October 7, 2024, one year after the massacre of Jews in Israel, CUAD published “a newspaper with a headline that used Hamas’s name for it: ‘One Year Since Al-Aqsa Flood, Revolution Until Victory’ . . . over a picture of Hamas fighters breaching the security fence to Israel.” CUAD also wants to undermine “US imperialism” because the group sees America as Israel’s chief ally. Khalil is no victim of conscience, no martyr for free speech.

Continue reading at National Review

10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

Why Reciprocal Trade Negotiations Will Fail

Economic Dynamism
Apr 30, 2025

When Life Becomes Unending Variations on Disease

Pursuit of Happiness
Apr 30, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Politics

Liberal Democracy Reexamined: Leo Strauss on Alexis de Tocqueville

This article explores Leo Strauss’s thoughts on Alexis de Tocqueville in his 1954 “Natural Right” course transcript.

Raúl Rodríguez
Politics
Feb 25, 2025
Long Distance Migration as a Two-Step Sorting Process: The Resettlement of Californians in Texas

Here we press the question of whether the well-documented stream of migrants relocating from California to Texas has been sufficient to alter the political complexion of the destination state.

James Gimpel, Daron Shaw
Politics
Feb 6, 2025
Who's That Knocking? A Study of the Strategic Choices Facing Large-Scale Grassroots Canvassing Efforts

Although there is a consensus that personalized forms of campaign outreach are more likely to be effective at either mobilizing or even persuading voters, there remains uncertainty about how campaigns should implement get-out-the-vote (GOTV) programs, especially at a truly expansive scale.

Grant Ferguson, James Gimpel, Mark Owens, Daron Shaw
Politics
Dec 13, 2024
National Poll from Civitas Institute: Trump Victory Driven by Voters Who Reject Status Quo

The poll asked 1,200 Americans an array of questions about how things are going in America.

Daron Shaw
Politics
Dec 11, 2024

The Three Whiskey Happy Hour

Steven Hayward brings you the Power Line Blog's perspective on the week's big headlines.

View all
** items
Relief for Trump in Sight — If Supreme Court Special Session Reins in Rogue Judges

Nationwide injunctions have proven a disaster for the federal judiciary.

John Yoo
Politics
Apr 25, 2025
The Dangers of the Political Gender Gap

Young women and men are gravitating towards opposite political extremes, with potentially explosive consequences.

Joel Kotkin
Politics
Apr 24, 2025
What Trump Can Learn from George W. Bush on Immigration Strategy

The White House should follow the Bush administration’s example and avoid antagonizing the Supreme Court.

John Yoo
Politics
Apr 23, 2025
Trump Could Have a Strong Case to Revoke Harvard’s Tax-Exempt Status

Thanks to a 1983 opinion widely hailed by progressives at the time, the administration could be on solid ground.

John Yoo, Robert Delahunty
Politics
Apr 21, 2025

John Yoo: The DOJ Is Being ‘Tricky’ but They May Be Right

Politics
Mar 18, 2025
1:05

John Yoo: How Will Trump Try to ‘Redirect’ the Justice Department Toward ‘Public Order and Safety’?

Politics
Mar 14, 2025
1:05

John Yoo: Musk’s Audits Are Part of Alexander Hamilton’s ‘Energetic Executive’

Politics
Feb 10, 2025
1:05

Lord Andrew Roberts on Winston Churchill and the US-UK Special Relationship, Then and Now

Politics
Sep 26, 2024
1:05

Justin Dyer on Civic Education: Live at AEI's Future of the American University Conference

Politics
May 14, 2024
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
The Ukraine-Russia Symposium

What does Ukraine mean to America?

Richard Reinsch
Politics
Apr 29, 2025
How Trump Should Answer Putin’s Foot-Dragging

Although Russia possesses the strategic initiative, its advantage over Ukraine isn’t decisive and can be eroded.

John Hardie
Politics
Apr 29, 2025
Ukraine's Cause Can Be Vindicated

Ukraine's cause for national freedom remains possible if America and Europe resolve to thwart Russian aggression.

Max Prowant
Politics
Apr 29, 2025
Ukraine: Beyond Tragedy and Self-Defeating Manichaeism

We in the West are morally and civically obliged to work to ensure that tragedy and inexpiable conflict do not have the final word.

Daniel J. Mahoney
Politics
Apr 29, 2025
No items found.