Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Economic Dynamism
Published on
Feb 5, 2025
Contributors
Richard Epstein
Benjamin Flowers
"Research Chemist in Lab" U.S. Department of Agriculture, Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why Failure-to-Market Claims Are Preempted Under Federal Law

Contributors
Richard Epstein
Richard Epstein
Senior Research Fellow
Richard Epstein
Benjamin Flowers
Benjamin Flowers
Benjamin Flowers
Summary
This short white paper addresses preemption arguments relevant to “failure to market” claims, which cover those cases in which plaintiffs allege that drug companies may be held liable for failing to bring to market, as quickly as possible, drugs that present (allegedly) fewer side effects than other, FDA-approved drugs already on the market.
Summary
This short white paper addresses preemption arguments relevant to “failure to market” claims, which cover those cases in which plaintiffs allege that drug companies may be held liable for failing to bring to market, as quickly as possible, drugs that present (allegedly) fewer side effects than other, FDA-approved drugs already on the market.
Listen to this article

A California appellate court invented out of whole cloth a new and troubling theory of tort liability. Specifically, the court held that drug companies have a duty to develop and bring to market drugs that are supposedly safer and more effective than another, FDA-approved drug the company sells already. The claim rested on factual premises contradicted by all publicly available information, the acceptance of which could seriously disrupt the FDA approval process. This disruption gives rise to an issue the parties did not raise on appeal and that the appeals court never addressed, notwithstanding the complex, comprehensive statutes governing drug approval: these state tort law claims are preempted under theories of both field and conflict (including obstacle) preemption. This White Paper explains why it is imperative for the federal government and private parties to advance these preemption arguments, and why the courts should accept them.

Read the Issue Brief

This white paper was originally published by the Pacific Research Institute's Center for Medical Economics and Innovation.

Keep Reading & Download PDF
10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

What Affirmative Action Has Wrought

Constitutionalism
Jul 14, 2025

Painting the Revolution

Politics
Jul 11, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Economic Dynamism

Automated Detection of Emotion in Central Bank Communication: A Warning

Can LLMs help us better understand the role of emotion in central bank communication?

Carola Binder, Nicole Baerg
Economic Dynamism
Jul 1, 2025
Defending Technological Dynamism & the Freedom to Innovate in the Age of AI

Human flourishing, economic growth, and geopolitical resilience requires innovation—especially in artificial intelligence.

Adam Thierer
Economic Dynamism
Jun 6, 2025
Partisan Trust in the Federal Reserve

This paper examines partisanship in public perceptions of the Federal Reserve.

Carola Binder, Cody Couture, Abhiprerna Smit
Economic Dynamism
Apr 22, 2025
The American Dream Is Not a Coin Flip, and Wages Have Not Stagnated

This paper challenges the prevailing narrative that stagnant wages are causing the American dream to fade. It contrasts subjective public opinion with revised objective intergenerational mobility measures.

Scott Winship
Economic Dynamism
Mar 6, 2025
No items found.
Firm Investment and the User Cost of Capital: New U.S. Corporate Tax Reform Evidence

This working paper analyzes the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 to examine how corporate tax reform impacts rates of investment.

Jonathan S. Hartley, Kevin A. Hassett, Joshua D. Rauh
Economic Dynamism
Jul 7, 2025
It’s Not Easy, but We Can All Learn to Think like Adam Smith

To truly understand what a dynamic economy requires, we would do well to recover the 18th-century sensibility that understood dynamism as a social and cultural phenomenon as much as an economic one.

Ryan Streeter
Economic Dynamism
Jun 18, 2025
Locked Out of the Dream: Regulation Making Homes Unaffordable Around the World

The first in a two-part series on the global housing crisis.

Joel Kotkin
Economic Dynamism
Jun 5, 2025
A Most Favored National Policy for Pharma Drugs Makes Sense

"Most favored nation" pricing can help make America's pharmaceutical marketplace more competitive.

Dirk Mateer
Economic Dynamism
May 19, 2025

Richard Epstein: Law and Economics of Public Sector Unions

Economic Dynamism
Jun 19, 2025
1:05

Can the U.S. Defense Industrial Base Meet Today’s Challenges?

Economic Dynamism
May 13, 2025
1:05

Virginia Postrel and Adam Thierer on Big Trends and Big Ideas in Dynamism

Economic Dynamism
Apr 29, 2025
1:05

Joel Mokyr on American Dynamism vs. Techno-pessimism

Economic Dynamism
Apr 29, 2025
1:05

Arthur Herman on Mobility, Markets, and Natural Law

Economic Dynamism
Apr 29, 2025
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
AI on the Brain

A new study predicts a "likely decrease in learning skills, as LLMs reduce the cognitive effort required for writing," translating to poorer long-term knowledge retention.

Rachel Lomasky
Economic Dynamism
Jul 10, 2025
Escape From New York

With Mamdani rising in New York, Texas can now offer New York’s leading businesses a package deal: relocate to Texas and list on the TXSE. Call it the Texas Two-Step.

Michael Toth
Economic Dynamism
Jul 7, 2025
Exploring the Future of Latin America and US Relations

The authors examine the promises and perils of the Trump administration and the new governments in Latin America, and look forward to a renewed dialogue with U.S.-based scholars at this moment of opportunity.

Oscar Sumar, John Yoo
Economic Dynamism
Jul 2, 2025
A New Consensus in Latin America

During Biden’s administration, U.S. policy appeared passive, even compromised, in the face of these revolutionary developments.

Oscar Sumar
Economic Dynamism
Jul 2, 2025
No items found.