Example Image
Civitas Outlook
Topic
Pursuit of Happiness
Published on
Jan 28, 2025
Contributors
Scott Carrell
Alexander J. Chesney
Image: A pleasant American college campus generated by ChatGPT (OpenAI, 01/28/2025)

Brains Versus Brawn: Ordinal Rank Effects in Job Training

Contributors
Scott Carrell
Scott Carrell
Senior Fellow
Scott Carrell
Alexander J. Chesney
Alexander J. Chesney
Alexander J. Chesney
Summary
Is it better to be a big fish in a small pond or a small fish in a big pond?
Summary
Is it better to be a big fish in a small pond or a small fish in a big pond?
Listen to this article

Using data from Air Force basic military training, Civitas Senior Fellow Scott Carrell and Alexander Chesney examine the impacts of relative rank in cognitive and physical ability on enlistees short and longer-run outcomes. Results show strong evidence for the “big fish, small pond” phenomenon, meaning that individuals of equal ability tend to thrive when they are higher on the proverbial pecking order of ability within their assigned group. Findings also suggest that overall group productivity could be improved by altering the way military personnel are assigned to training groups.

Read the Full Paper

This paper was originally published by the Journal of Public Economics.

Continue Reading & Download PDF
10:13
1x
10:13
More articles

Junk the CAFE Standards

Pursuit of Happiness
Dec 12, 2025

“Brazenly Partisan” Judges Scrutinize Trump’s Mind, But Refuse To Explain Themselves

Politics
Dec 11, 2025
View all

Join the newsletter

Receive new publications, news, and updates from the Civitas Institute.

Sign up
More on

Pursuit of Happiness

The Rise of Latino America

In The Rise of Latino America, Hernandez & Kotkin argue that Latinos, who are projected to become America’s largest ethnic group, are a dynamic force shaping the nation’s demographic, economic, and cultural future. Far from being a marginalized group defined by oppression, Latinos are integral to America’s story. They drive economic growth, cultural evolution, and workforce vitality. Challenges, however, including poverty, educational disparities, and restrictive policies, threaten their upward mobility. Policymakers who wish to harness Latino potential to ensure national prosperity and resilience should adopt policies that prioritize affordability, safety, and economic opportunity over ideological constraints.

Joel Kotkin, Jennifer Hernandez, Wendell Cox, Marshall Toplansky, Erika Ozuna
Pursuit of Happiness
Nov 10, 2025
Revival: Americans Heading Back to the Hinterlands

Smaller communities throughout the country are poised to play an outsize role in forging our future.

Joel Kotkin, Wendell Cox
Pursuit of Happiness
Sep 19, 2025
How to Save Our Urban Centers

What will the future of American cities look like?

Joel Kotkin
Pursuit of Happiness
Jun 26, 2025
National Poll from Civitas Institute: Americans Concerned About AI, Economic Issues

The Civitas Institute Poll, conducted from March 11-20, 2025, asked 1,200 Americans an array of questions about how things are going in the country.

Daron Shaw
Pursuit of Happiness
Jun 11, 2025
Peter Robinson Unbridled - A Civitas Institute Podcast

Peter Robinson Unbridled

A new show and podcast bringing the energy of Austin to wide-ranging conversations on politics, economics, education, and culture.

View all
** items
Exodus: Affordability Crisis Sends Americans Packing From Big Cities

The first in a two-part series about the Great Dispersion of Americans across the country.

Joel Kotkin, Wendell Cox
Pursuit of Happiness
Sep 9, 2025
Stanford’s Graduate Student Union Tries to Stifle Dissent

The university may fire me because I won’t pay dues to a labor organization whose views I find repugnant.

Jonathan Hartley
Pursuit of Happiness
Aug 29, 2025
The 529 Education Revolution Is Here

Tax-free accounts have become more powerful, but some states are resisting.

Michael Toth, Dan Lips
Pursuit of Happiness
Aug 28, 2025
The Next Californias

Colorado, Washington, and Oregon have adopted many of the policies contributing to the Golden State’s decline.

Joel Kotkin
Pursuit of Happiness
Aug 25, 2025

Robert George and Cornel West - Truth Matters, A Book Talk

Pursuit of Happiness
Sep 26, 2025
1:05

Arthur Brooks on the Secret to a Fulfilling Life

Pursuit of Happiness
Jul 7, 2025
1:05

Populism Unpacked: Voices from the Heartland

Pursuit of Happiness
Mar 4, 2025
1:05

Jeff Rosen on What “The Pursuit of Happiness” Meant to America's Founders

Pursuit of Happiness
Jan 26, 2025
1:05

Arthur C. Brooks on the Pursuit of Happiness in an Unhappy World

Pursuit of Happiness
May 8, 2024
1:05
No items found.
No items found.
Junk the CAFE Standards

The regulation of air pollution, like that of any other dangerous externality, only works if the appropriate regulatory scheme is put in place at the outset, and that is where the current CAFE framework is fatally defective.

Richard Epstein
Pursuit of Happiness
Dec 12, 2025
The Significance of “Getting Cheaper” Efficiency

Potter seeks to answer the following question that microeconomists and academics alike reject: How do processes get more efficient?

Michael Munger
Pursuit of Happiness
Dec 10, 2025
Ken Burns' Egregious Omission

Ken Burns doesn’t smear the Founders, but he egregiously omits the courage and tireless work it took not only to declare independence, but to fight for it.

Pursuit of Happiness
Dec 5, 2025
A National Day of Gratitude

Washington’s Proclamation expressed hope that God would “render our national government a blessing to all the people, by constantly being a Government of wise, just, and constitutional laws, discreetly and faithfully executed and obeyed…”

Pursuit of Happiness
Nov 27, 2025
No items found.